722 E. Market St. Marietta, PA 17547Phone: (717)426-8415
Where to Go Thrifting in Lancaster County, PA
Affordable shopping…who doesn’t love a good bargain? Thrift stores have a special kind of charm that combines nostalgia with the thrill of discovery. Walking through the aisles can feel a little like a treasure hunt. Vintage fashion, classic books, quirky collectibles, and unique home décor are often tucked among everyday items, just waiting to be rediscovered. Even if you’re not an avid thrifter, popping into a secondhand shop while exploring Lancaster County can be a fun way to spend an afternoon. Guests staying at the B.F. Hiestand House Bed and Breakfast often discover that a quick thrift stop can turn into an unexpected adventure.
Part of the fun is never knowing what you’ll find. One shelf might hold a stack of well-loved novels while the next reveals antique glassware or artwork from decades past. Each store has its own personality, shaped by the donations that come through the door and the community that supports it. The variety makes Lancaster’s thrift stores a perfect outing for budget-conscious shoppers and anyone who enjoys a little nostalgia.
Thrifting also comes with a feel-good bonus. Buying secondhand helps give new life to items that might otherwise end up in the trash, which makes it a small but meaningful step toward sustainability. Many of Lancaster County’s thrift stores also support charitable organizations. That means your bargain find may also help fund community programs or relief efforts around the world. Knowing your purchase contributes to a good cause adds another layer of satisfaction to the experience.
During your next visit to Lancaster County, consider stopping by a few of these favorite local thrift shops.
Thrift shopping with a purpose has been the focus of Mt. Joy Gift & Thrift since it first opened in 1977. In March 2025, the store moved into a new, larger space at 3141 Mount Joy Road in Mount Joy, across from The Country Store, after decades at its former location on West Main Street. The shop is part of a network of more than 100 thrift stores that benefit the Mennonite Central Committee and its worldwide relief efforts.
Local bargain hunters love Mt. Joy Gift & Thrift for its reasonable prices and ever-changing selection. Clothing and accessories fill the racks, while shelves display housewares, books, antiques, and collectibles. Donations arrive regularly, so the inventory is always evolving. A quick stop can easily turn into a long browse.
Another favorite that supports the Mennonite Central Committee is the Columbia Re-Uzit Shop, located at 363 Locust Street in Columbia. Shoppers come here for the same reasons people love thrift stores everywhere: great prices and the excitement of the unexpected.
The store carries everything from tools and toys to furniture and seasonal décor. Trinkets, collectibles, and household goods appear in every corner. Many visitors describe the experience as a true treasure hunt. Each purchase also supports relief efforts locally and around the world, making it a shopping adventure with both heart and purpose.
Jubilee Ministries Thrift Stores
Jubilee Ministries operates six thrift stores throughout Lancaster, Lebanon, and Berks counties, along with an online shop. Proceeds help fund Jubilee’s prison ministry, which serves individuals and families affected by incarceration.
The location closest to the B.F. Hiestand House sits about 20 minutes away at 27 E. Ferdinand Street in Manheim. Opened in 2008, the store features racks and racks of clothing along with kitchen goods, electronics, picture frames, jewelry, designer purses, and plenty of home décor. Shoppers never quite know what will appear on the shelves next, which keeps the experience fresh and exciting.
CommunityAid is a faith-based nonprofit that partners with more than 800 organizations to support neighbors in need. Its Lancaster County store at 31 Rohrerstown Road in Lancaster offers an enormous selection of gently used items at affordable prices.
Clothing for the entire family fills the racks, while the rest of the store features shoes, purses, jewelry, furniture, wall art, mirrors, and household goods. The store’s Facebook page regularly showcases unique finds and gives shoppers a preview of the treasures waiting inside.
Fashion Cents Consignment blends thrift store pricing with a boutique-style experience. Founder Brittany Allen opened the first location in Strasburg in 2012, taking a leap of faith that quickly paid off. The business has since grown to five stores throughout Lancaster County.
The original shop at 255 North Decatur Street in Strasburg is especially fun to explore while visiting Amish Country. The modest entrance doesn’t reveal just how large the store is. Inside, you’ll find more than 11,000 square feet filled with clothing, shoes, accessories, and stylish home goods. The selection feels almost endless, making it easy to spend time browsing.
A Treasure Hunt Worth Taking
Thrift stores add a fun twist to any Lancaster County getaway. You might walk in looking for a bargain and leave with a vintage jacket, a stack of classic books, or a quirky piece of art that reminds you of your trip. The thrill of the hunt, the nostalgic finds, and the knowledge that many of these stores support good causes all make the experience even better.
When you stay in one of our six cozy and uniquely styled rooms in our Victorian B&B, you’re perfectly positioned to explore many of these shops while discovering the charm of Lancaster County. A day of thrifting can easily fit between scenic drives, farmers’ markets, and visits to nearby small towns. Just remember to leave a little room in your suitcase for those unexpected treasures.
